%---------------- SGGS v1.0 (IJCAR 2020 submission) ----------------%

------ Parsing...successful


------ Proving...
flip all literals with predicate richer
use I-

Gamma_0: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)

Gamma_1: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))

Gamma_2: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]

Gamma_3: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]

Gamma_4: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_5: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [hates(agatha,agatha)]

Gamma_6: (extend-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,
agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  6: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]

Gamma_7: (move)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]

Gamma_8: (resolve)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]
  6: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]

Gamma_9: (extend-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,
agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]
  6: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]

Gamma_10: (move)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  6: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]

Gamma_11: (resolve)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_12: (extend-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,
agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_13: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  2: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  3: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_14: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_15: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_16: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))

Gamma_17: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]

Gamma_18: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]

Gamma_19: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_20: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]

Gamma_21: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,butler)], ~(lives(butler))

Gamma_22: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,butler)], ~(lives(butler))
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_23: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,butler)], ~(lives(butler))

Gamma_24: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), ~(
lives(butler))

Gamma_25: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]

Gamma_26: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  10: [lives(butler)]
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_27: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  10: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_28: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_29: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  7: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_30: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  7: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [~(killed(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles))
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_31: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  7: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_32: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  6: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  7: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_33: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  6: [~(killed(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles))
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_34: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_35: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  6: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_36: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_37: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_38: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_39: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  4: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_40: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  4: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_41: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  2: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  3: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_42: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  2: []
  3: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  5: [lives(charles)]

SZS status Unsatisfiable

%---------------- SGGS v1.0 (IJCAR 2020 submission) ----------------%

------ Parsing...successful


------ Proving...
flip all literals with predicate richer
use I-

Gamma_0: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)

Gamma_1: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))

Gamma_2: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]

Gamma_3: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]

Gamma_4: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_5: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(
butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [hates(agatha,agatha)]

Gamma_6: (extend-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,
agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  6: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]

Gamma_7: (move)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]

Gamma_8: (resolve)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]
  6: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]

Gamma_9: (extend-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,
agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]
  6: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]

Gamma_10: (move)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(charles,agatha)), [hates(charles,agatha)]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  6: ~(hates(charles,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,agatha))]

Gamma_11: (resolve)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_12: (extend-conflict)
  0: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,
agatha)
  1: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_13: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(charles,agatha)], killed(butler,agatha)
  2: [richer(charles,agatha)], ~(killed(charles,agatha))
  3: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_14: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_15: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))

Gamma_16: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))

Gamma_17: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]

Gamma_18: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]

Gamma_19: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_20: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]

Gamma_21: (extend-no-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,butler)], ~(lives(butler))

Gamma_22: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,butler)], ~(lives(butler))
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_23: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,butler)], ~(lives(butler))

Gamma_24: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), ~(
lives(butler))

Gamma_25: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: [lives(butler)]
  10: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]

Gamma_26: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  10: [lives(butler)]
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_27: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  10: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha))
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_28: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]
  9: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_29: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  7: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [hates(butler,agatha)]
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]
  10: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), ~(hates(butler,agatha)), [~(
lives(butler))]
  11: ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,butler))], ~(hates(butler,agatha))

Gamma_30: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  7: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), [~(killed(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles))
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_31: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  6: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  7: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_32: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  6: [richer(butler,agatha)], ~(killed(butler,agatha))
  7: ~(richer(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles)), [~(hates(butler,agatha))]
  8: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  9: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_33: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  6: [~(killed(butler,agatha))], ~(hates(butler,charles))
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_34: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  5: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  6: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_35: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  5: [hates(butler,charles)], ~(hates(agatha,charles))
  6: [~(richer(butler,agatha))], ~(killed(butler,agatha)), ~(hates(butler,charles))
  7: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  8: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_36: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_37: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_38: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  4: [hates(agatha,charles)]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_39: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  4: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_40: (extend-conflict)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  2: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  3: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  4: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_41: (move)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  2: [killed(butler,agatha)]
  3: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  4: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(agatha,charles))]
  5: ~(killed(butler,agatha)), [~(hates(butler,charles))]
  6: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  7: [lives(charles)]

Gamma_42: (resolve)
  0: [~(killed(charles,agatha))]
  1: [~(killed(butler,agatha))]
  2: []
  3: [~(hates(charles,agatha))]
  4: [hates(agatha,agatha)]
  5: [lives(charles)]

SZS status Unsatisfiable